How A lot Ought to You Put in Your Kid’s 529 Faculty Account? What If It is Too A lot?


Your youngster is 2 years outdated. You wish to save for his or her faculty. The reply to “The place ought to I save?” is straightforward sufficient. The larger, more durable query is: “How a lot ought to I save?”

(Even when your youngster is 16 years outdated, the query continues to be laborious to reply.)

We work with loads of {couples} with kids from 0 to varsity age, and we get this query from just about each one in every of them. Right here’s how we assist our purchasers reply that query.

[Note: In this article, we’re talking about situations in which you can contribute more to the 529 plan if you want to. It’s another matter entirely if you simply don’t have enough money to save much to the 529.]

Why Is It So Arduous to Know How A lot to Save for Faculty?

As a result of you haven’t any concept how a lot faculty will value.

In case your youngster is 2, every little thing is unsure. Before everything, nobody is aware of how a lot faculty prices will change over the following 16 years (and it could possibly be substantial!).

Some points will get clearer as your youngster approaches faculty age:

  • Will your youngster even go to varsity?
  • Is your youngster more likely to get monetary help?

However there are some points that can probably stay just about simply as murky:

  • What faculty will settle for your youngster?
  • Which faculty will your youngster wish to go to?
  • How a lot will it value?
  • Will your youngster get any scholarships?

So, your youngster’s faculty may find yourself costing $0 (no faculty in any respect, full journey someplace, or the navy pays for it), $30,000/12 months (in-state public faculty), or $80,000/12 months (Harvard and its ilk).

529 Plans Can Be a Nice Place to Save for Faculty

529 plans are a great way to save lots of for school as a result of they’ll prevent in taxes, maybe meaningfully.

Why? As a result of they work roughly like a Roth 401(ok) or Roth IRA. Does that comparability not assist in the least? What I imply by it’s this:

  1. You get no tax breaks once you put cash into the 529. (Some states do present state revenue tax deductions. They’re normally fairly small.)
  2. Because the investments develop (hopefully), you pay no taxes on any of the expansion.
  3. If you promote your investments and take the cash out of the 529 with a purpose to pay for school, each your contributions and all of the earnings come out tax free.

Fairly candy! When you make investments cash for 18 years, that may be fairly the tax financial savings!

…Besides When You Don’t Want All of the 529 Cash

The draw back is: When you put more cash within the 529 than you have to pay to your youngster’s faculty, you possibly can pay taxes and penalties on that extra cash.

When you take cash out of the 529 not for eligible training bills, it’s a must to pay revenue taxes and a ten% penalty on the earnings. (Your contributions come out tax- and penalty-free.)

That could possibly be painful!

[Added 8/10/2023, thanks to a helpful colleague on Twitter.] There is a vital exception: “In case your youngster attends a Service Academy, you possibly can withdraw 529 Funds based mostly on the “Equal Value”, which the Service Academy publishes yearly. You keep away from the penalty, although you pay taxes on the positive aspects as bizarre revenue.” The identical guidelines apply in case your youngster will get a scholarship and that scholarship cash renders the 529 cash “an excessive amount of.”

You continue to should pay bizarre revenue tax on the positive aspects. When you had invested the cash in a plain ol’ taxable funding account, you’d solely be paying the normally decrease capital positive aspects tax on the positive aspects. In order that’s nonetheless one rely in opposition to 529s. That stated, as my colleague factors out, the entire cause you now have an extra of cash in your 529 is: YOU DON’T HAVE TO PAY AS MUCH IN TUITION. So, on the entire, you’re a winner, darling.]

So, how will we steadiness getting the tax advantages of placing cash into the 529, however avoiding the taxes and penalties if we put too a lot cash in?

A Good Technique: Put a Conservative Quantity within the 529

As a result of we do not know how a lot your youngster will finally must pay for school, I actually like the concept of placing a conservative amount of cash into the 529. The quantity contributed will get the tax advantages, however you’re fairly positive to not save “an excessive amount of” into it.

What does “conservative” imply? It’s undoubtedly subjective, however listed below are some solutions I like:

  • Save sufficient to the 529 for a lower-cost faculty (like an in-state faculty).

    Then save a bunch extra in a taxable account for any remaining value, as a backup. You may take cash out of a taxable funding account at any time, with no penalty, and the tax you pay would be the capital positive aspects tax, which is normally decrease than the revenue tax.

    Or, if you happen to’re excessive revenue, you possibly can plan to pay any extra prices out of your money stream within the faculty years.

  • Save roughly ⅓ of your guessed-at prices to the 529.

    This comes from recommendation I heard years in the past from a school professional: Plan to pay faculty bills ⅓ from previous revenue, ⅓ from present revenue, and ⅓ from future revenue (which is to say ⅓ from financial savings, ⅓ out of your paycheck, and ⅓ in loans).

Helpful Methods to Cope with “Too A lot Cash” in Your Youngster’s 529

So you find yourself with an excessive amount of cash in your youngster’s 529 in any case. There are a number of good methods of coping with this. It doesn’t should be a “downside” in any respect!

The New Hotness: Kickstart Your Youngster’s Retirement Financial savings by Transferring It to their Roth IRA.

As I wrote about on this weblog put up concerning the SECURE Act 2.0, handed into legislation in 2022

You may convert cash from the 529 (that your youngster is a beneficiary of) right into a Roth IRA owned by your youngster. The surplus cash within the 529 can thus be transmuted from “for use for training” to “for use for retirement” with none penalty or tax.

Sounds nice! However there are a ton of restrictions:

  • Your youngster has to truly earn cash (as in, jobbity job) with a purpose to put any of that 529 cash into their Roth IRA in any given 12 months. 
  • The 529 will need to have been maintained for 15+ years.
    When you opened the 529 round when your youngster was born, then by the point faculty is approaching, this requirement is definitely glad.
  • Contributions made to the 529 inside the earlier 5 years can’t be moved.
  • Every year you possibly can convert solely as much as the IRA contribution restrict. In 2023, you’ll solely be capable of convert $6500. 
  • There’s additionally a lifetime cap on conversion of $35,000.

So, if you happen to overfund by $100,000? This tactic can solely assist a lot. However maybe together with different ways beneath, it may be a part of a full answer.

Let your youngster use it for graduate faculty.

In case your youngster’s faculty doesn’t value as a lot as you’ve got saved within the 529, they’ll all the time use the remaining cash for graduate faculty, and even some types of skilled growth (assuming that the training is offered by eligible suppliers). 

On this case, you don’t should do something. Simply let the account sit and the investments proceed to develop (hopefully).

Change the beneficiary on the 529.

You may change the beneficiary (the one that will get to make use of the cash) on the 529 as typically as you want. (Try this text for extra particulars.)

So, if there may be extra within the 529 than Youngster #1 wants for his or her faculty bills, you possibly can all the time use what they want from the 529, after which change the beneficiary to Youngster #2, for their faculty bills. Or change it to your self! Or you possibly can wait till your youngster has a toddler, and alter the beneficiary to your grandchild! You may change the beneficiary to many different relations additionally, inside limits.

[Note: In what is admittedly probably a corner case, once 529 balances get really high, and you’re changing beneficiaries from one generation to the next, like from your child to your grandchild (and especially next next, like from your child to their grandchild), you could run into some estate tax and generation-skipping transfer tax challenges. If you plan to change the beneficiary from, say, your child, to your grandchild, talk with a CPA and/or estate planning attorney, and perhaps take a peek at this very detailed article about this issue.]

So, actually, placing “an excessive amount of” into your youngster’s 529 won’t be a lot of a problem in any case. For these of us who don’t have limitless sources and nonetheless must resolve between saving for school and saving for different priorities, nevertheless, I hope you now have a greater concept of the way to greatest use 529s for your household’s particular wants.

If you wish to work with a planner who may help you give your youngster the sort of faculty expertise they deserve, attain out and schedule a free session or ship us an e-mail.

Join Movement’s twice-monthly weblog e-mail to remain on prime of our weblog posts and movies.

Disclaimer: This text is offered for academic, common data, and illustration functions solely. Nothing contained within the materials constitutes tax recommendation, a suggestion for buy or sale of any safety, or funding advisory providers. We encourage you to seek the advice of a monetary planner, accountant, and/or authorized counsel for recommendation particular to your scenario. Replica of this materials is prohibited with out written permission from Movement Monetary Planning, LLC, and all rights are reserved. Learn the complete Disclaimer.


Leave a Comment