Carlyle Deal, Transitioning to CLO Fairness Fund


Final week, Vertical Capital Earnings Fund (VCIF) ($98MM market cap) introduced a proposed supervisor and technique change, if accredited, Carlyle Group (CG) will assume administration of the closed finish fund and transition the portfolio from residential entire loans to CLO fairness and debt.  To encourage the proposal passing, Carlyle will make a one-time fee to VCIF holders of $10MM or $0.96/share.  Then to make sure alignment, Carlyle will tender for $25MM at NAV and make investments a further $25MM within the fund by way of a non-public placement accomplished at NAV.  Following these transactions, Carlyle will personal ~40% of the fund.

CLO stands for collateralized mortgage obligation, these are securitized swimming pools of below-investment grade senior secured financial institution loans made to companies (largely PE sponsored).  CLO fairness sits on the backside of the securitization’s capital construction and receives the residual money circulate in spite of everything bills and curiosity is paid to senior noteholders within the transaction.  CLO notes characteristic time period financing with no mark-to-market, that means CLOs can face up to volatility within the underlying financial institution mortgage market and sometimes the supervisor can “construct par” to offset any losses within the portfolio by buying loans at a reduction and holding them by way of compensation at par.  CLO fairness is usually underwritten to a mid-teens IRR.  There are a number of publicly traded CLO fairness funds at present, two distinguished ones are Eagle Level Credit score Firm (ECC) and Oxford Lane Capital (OXLC), each commerce roughly inline with NAV or barely forward (NAV is lagging, loans are up 1.80% thus far, CLO fairness values are seemingly up a bit).

Carlyle is likely one of the largest CLO managers, by taking up this fund, the PE big can have a everlasting supply of fairness capital for future CLOs.  That is essential for future fund formation and why Carlyle is prepared to pay $10MM to holders immediately.  Charges to fund holders are going up within the transition as properly (however roughly on par with related funds/BDCs), VCIF at present pays 1.25% of belongings, now pays 1.75% of belongings plus a 17.5% incentive price above an 8% hurdle fee.  Carlyle does get to double dip a bit, they will seemingly buy Carlyle Group managed CLOs the place additionally they earn a administration price.

VCIF at present trades for $9.38/share in opposition to a 12/31 NAV of $10.25/share, or an 8.5% low cost (with out factoring within the $0.96/share fee).  The vote is generally secured at this level, 36% of shareholders have signed a help settlement.  I shortly sketched out what the return stream would possibly appear like within the subsequent six months (the deal is ready to shut within the first half of 2023):

The largest assumptions I am making:

  • NAV is fixed, the portfolio is marked month-to-month, the present holdings are mortgages with rate of interest sensitivity, it’s going to transfer inversely with fee expectations (mortgage charges are flat-to-slightly down YTD).  As a part of the transaction, present administration has dedicated liquidating to money a minimum of 95% of the gross belongings within the portfolio, thus decreasing the NAV threat.
  • Solely the January distribution is made and it does not erode NAV.  Further curiosity earnings we’ll assume goes to pay for any deal bills the fund is predicted to pay.
  • All holders take part at 100% within the tender supply.  If lower than 100% take part, it improves the realized IRR.
  • Following the transition, the shares commerce at a 15% low cost to NAV.  Within the final 12 months, the fund’s shares have traded at a mean low cost of 12% and as talked about earlier, the distinguished CLO fairness funds commerce roughly in keeping with NAV.

I give you a ~18% IRR for the 5+ months it’s going to take to shut this deal (feels prefer it ought to occur sooner pushing the IRR above 20%) and would possibly maintain after closing when will probably be rebranded as Carlyle Credit score Earnings since CLO fairness within reason low cost at present.

Disclosure: I personal shares of VCIF 


Leave a Comment