Canada tax system not constructed to maintain up with inflation, report finds


Jamie Golombek: Not all taxes are listed, creating distortions that amplify the consequences of rising costs, C.D. Howe report says

Article content material

Inflation has been on the highest of many Canadians’ minds not too long ago, with the year-over-year enhance within the shopper worth index (CPI) hitting a four-decade excessive of 8.1 per cent in June 2022. Whereas inflation has began to chill, when the consequences of upper inflation are mixed with tax provisions that primarily ignore it, “the ache for earners, savers, and recipients of advantages,” will be multiplied, in keeping with a brand new report issued this week by the C.D. Howe Institute.

Commercial 2

Article content material

In “Double the Ache: How Inflation Will increase Tax Burdens,” the C.D. Howe Institute’s William Robson and Alex Laurin establish problematic interactions between inflation and taxes and spotlight some fixes, notably indexing varied thresholds and quantities to the CPI, and never making issues worse for traders by doubtlessly growing the capital good points inclusion charge.

Article content material

Earlier than delving into a number of the particular findings of the report, let’s take a step again and assessment the present indexing system and the way varied tax objects are adjusted for inflation.

Most (however not all) earnings tax and profit quantities are listed to inflation. You’ll recall that in November 2022, the Canada Income Company introduced the inflation charge that may be used to index the 2023 tax brackets and profit quantities could be 6.3 per cent. Will increase to the tax-bracket thresholds and varied quantities regarding non-refundable credit took impact on Jan. 1, 2023. However will increase for sure advantages, such because the GST/HST credit score and Canada Youngster Profit, solely took impact not too long ago, as of July 1, 2023, which coincides with the start of this system yr for these profit funds.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

All 5 federal earnings tax brackets for 2023 had been listed to inflation utilizing the 6.3-per-cent charge. This makes Canada fairly distinctive. The C.D. Howe report notes {that a} current survey of 160 international locations revealed that 131 of them don’t index tax thresholds in order that they rise with inflation. In actual fact, solely 9 international locations, Canada amongst them, have laws or laws in place mandating computerized periodic changes consistent with inflation.

Every province additionally has its personal set of provincial tax brackets, and most do index them to inflation utilizing their respective provincial indexation elements. However, not all provinces are on board. For instance, the report famous that Alberta didn’t index its thresholds in 2020 and 2021. Manitoba didn’t index its tax system to inflation earlier than 2017. Nova Scotia and P.E.I. don’t index any of their thresholds, and Ontario doesn’t index its high two earnings thresholds of $150,000 and $220,000, quantities that had been fastened in 2014. The result’s that for higher-income Ontarians, inflation has eroded their worth to $120,000 and $176,000 in 2014 {dollars}.

Commercial 4

Article content material

Whereas most credit and a few deductions, akin to the essential private quantity, partner quantity, age quantity, and so forth. are additionally listed to inflation, others usually are not. For instance, the authors be aware that the utmost greenback limits beneath the child-care expense deduction, though raised periodically because the deduction was first launched again in 1972, usually are not adjusted for inflation. The utmost quantity of child-care bills that may be claimed per youngster beneath seven years previous is at the moment $8,000. Twenty-five years in the past, the utmost was … $7,000. Adjusted for inflation, mother and father would doubtlessly have the ability to deduct as much as $12,000 per youngster in 2023, an quantity that’s 50 per cent greater than the quantity they will at the moment deduct.

Different examples of quantities that haven’t been listed embrace the federal pension earnings credit score (caught at $2,000) and the utmost tuition credit score that may be transferred to a partner or associate or mother or father (nonetheless at $5,000).

On the company aspect, the small enterprise deduction, which is on the market to personal companies (together with skilled companies), supplies small companies with a decrease federal and provincial company tax charge on the primary $500,000 of web earnings. This $500,000 threshold hasn’t been modified since 2009, which means its actual worth has been lower by greater than 1 / 4.

Commercial 5

Article content material

In an analogous vein, again in 2019, the federal government launched guidelines to claw again the small enterprise deduction for personal firms that earn over $50,000 in passive earnings (primarily, funding earnings). The $50,000 threshold hasn’t been adjusted in 5 years.

The dearth of inflation changes additionally impacts consumption taxes, akin to the products and providers tax/harmonized gross sales tax (GST/HST). For instance, the GST/HST techniques have thresholds that decide whether or not a enterprise should acquire the taxes or whether or not a transaction is taxable, and inflation erodes the actual worth of those thresholds.

The authors astutely level out that the $30,000 small-supplier threshold for registering and amassing the GST has not modified because the institution of the GST again in 1991. After greater than 30 years, inflation has lower its actual worth virtually in half. And, annually, as inflation additional erodes the brink, extra companies should register and acquire GST. However the potential advantages of registering to say enter tax credit, the falling actual worth of the registration threshold creates administrative and compliance prices for a lot of small companies who could in any other case select to not register.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Lastly, the authors be aware that inflation and taxes additionally play a job in lowering the actual returns traders web, “turning nominal good points into actual losses.” They cite the instance of a one-year assured funding certificates (GIC), with a present yield of about 4.4 per cent. With inflation additionally not too long ago at 4.4 per cent, that produces an actual return of zero. However as a result of traders are taxed on the nominal curiosity, at a tax charge of, say, 40 per cent, the GIC’s after-tax yield drops to about 2.6 per cent — a return that, in actual phrases, is a lack of 1.8 per cent.

An identical evaluation will be made with respect to capital good points tax. In 2018, former U.S. president Donald Trump floated the concept of indexing capital good points to inflation, however it was finally deserted because it was perceived to largely profit upper-income taxpayers.

As for Canada, the authors readily acknowledge that offering tax recognition of the inflation part of curiosity and dividends is “technically daunting,” and so they discourage the federal government from growing the capital good points inclusion charge (at the moment at 50 per cent), “which might be a very dangerous transfer when inflation has already elevated the actual burden of capital good points taxes.”

Jamie Golombek, CPA, CA, CFP, CLU, TEP is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Personal Wealth in Toronto. [email protected]

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. Now we have enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail in the event you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a person you observe feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Tips for extra info and particulars on how you can alter your electronic mail settings.

Be part of the Dialog


Leave a Comment